My mom wanted to make cheese for her birthday, but the day of the party she took ill so everything was called off. That didn’t change the fact that I still had 2 gallons of milk in the refrigerator (one of which was fancy raw milk from Vashon, which seemed like it might go bad at any moment, since I bought it with bright orange $2.00 off stickers on each half-gallon. Which still meant it was $5.99 / half gallon by the way. Yikes.)
Anyway, I got to the task a couple days later, and followed the instructions from this website. It all went relatively smoothly (despite the fact that yes, that is a thermometer for people, not cheese, normally), and it took close to 3 hours start-to-finish. I was pretty impressed with the final product, arrived at through a combination of kneading curds and microwaving them for short bursts. The finished ball of cheese bears an uncanny resemblance to pizza dough.
However, it is only partially satisfying when you basically make something that tastes like what it’s supposed to taste like… I wasn’t expecting transcendent cheese, but for all the effort it too, it should be something special. It tasted good, and it’s going to make awesome pizza, but I don’t see putting this project into the weekly rotation.
I ended up cutting it up in chunks and putting in a container with some of the leftover whey to keep it fresh. I’m not sure if you’re supposed to do that, but it seemed to make sense.
The bonus was that you could boil the leftover whey at the end (which looked like about 90% of the volume I started with) and strain that to make a small quantity of ricotta. And I mean small… maybe a 1/2 cup. But something’s better than nothing.



Some postscript notes:
1. It turned out that storing the cheese in the whey was a bad idea; it just got soggy. I’m not sure what the difference between that and the little balls of mozzarella they sell in the store packed in liquid, but I think it may have to do with the fact that it was cut up, rather than formed into a ball.
2. The preferred method of storage after the initial soggy cheese debacle was to wrap them in a slightly damp rag and store them in a ziplock bag. They stayed at a nice consistency that way until I got around to making some tasty enchiladas.
Share on Facebook